• Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Ethics
  • Submissions
  • Contact Us

Grimag

  • Popular
  • #GamerGate
  • Topics
    • Culture
    • Industry
    • News
    • Opinion
    • Retro Games
    • Reviews
  • Submit An Article
Home A Response To Anita Sarkeesian’s Demands Upon The Gaming Industry

A Response To Anita Sarkeesian’s Demands Upon The Gaming Industry

Sam Roberts

Sam Roberts is the ethics officer for Reaxxion. Think we're doing something wrong? Want to chat? You can follow him on twitter, or email him from our ethics policy page.

February 28, 2015 News
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Earlier this week, noted feminist and gaming opponent Anita Sarkeesian, of the 300 million dollar Intel money, published a list of “Eight Things Developers Can Do To Make Games Less Shitty For Women.” (As an aside, what is it with feminists and swearing? Is it some attempt to fight against stereotypes of being “ladylike”?) While feminist whining about video games is nothing new, this is, to my knowledge, their first attempt at a list of demands for the game industry.  Thus even though these are arguments we’ve all seen before, it’s worth going through them and responding to each in turn, and giving them the due consideration that these ideas and their proponents deserve.  I’ve bolded each demand below, along with my response.

1. Avoid the Smurfette principle (don’t have just one female character in an ensemble cast, let alone one whose personality is more or less “girl” or “woman.”)

My response: No.

borderlands-characters-full

2. “Lingerie is not armor” (Dress female characters as something other than sex objects.)

My response: No.

IvyArmor

3. Have female characters of various body types

My response: No.

 DOA5U_groupD_TeamA_all

 4. Don’t over-emphasize female characters’ rear ends, not any more than you would the average male character’s

My response: No.

CammyButt

 5. Include more female characters of color.

My response: No.

final_fantasy_13_girls_foto_by_serenakaori87-d4bptbl

6. Animate female characters to move the way normal women, soldiers or athletes would move.

My response: No.

BayonettaWalkingGif

7. Record female character voiceover so that pain sounds painful, not orgasmic.

My response: What the hell are you talking about? What sort of weird sicko says, “I want the voiceovers in my game to sound painful! I won’t be satisfied until those women really sound like they’re having their intestines torn out by a tiger”? Get help, woman.

I don't have a picture for this, and I don't really want to think about it too much. Let's all look at this picture of a cat with bread around its face instead.

I don’t have a picture for this, and I don’t really want to think about it too much. Let’s all look at this picture of a cat with bread around its face instead.

8. Include female enemies, but don’t sexualize those enemies.

My response: No.

Jeanne_gun

These responses may seem a little brief, and perhaps juvenile.  I maintain, however, that “no” is the only way to answer these demands.  The temptation is always to say that Ms. Sarkeesian misrepresents the gaming industry, that there are actually plenty of female-friendly games, or that characters like the ones above are “strong women”, whom feminists should love.  This is the wrong answer.  By making this argument, you’re implicitly agreeing with Sarkeesian and her like that games need to be feminist-friendly; you’re just disagreeing on how feminist-friendly they are right now.  And once you’ve agreed with her there, you’ve given her the power to dictate what is and isn’t allowed.  After all, who’s going to know better about what games are SJW-friendly—you, or a women’s studies major?

The only response is this: If you don’t like games with big-boobed girls, don’t play them.  Even granting Ms. Sarkeesian’s arguments, there is no need for gaming to be “less shitty” to women, any more than there is a need for Lifetime original movies or romance novels to be “less shitty” to men.  There are many things in this world that don’t appeal to any given person.  But adults recognize that not everything is meant for them.  Men don’t barge into the local girl’s night out and angrily demand that women stop insulting their husbands and boyfriends.  No man has started a petition against 50 Shades of Grey, and said that its portrayal of a billionaire hunk with an S&M fetish is an unrealistic picture of modern masculinity.

Ms. Sarkeesian, you do not get to tell us how to have fun, and you do not get to tell game developers how to earn their living.  And if it upsets you that much that games don’t have more women screaming in realistic pain, I’d suggest taking some of that grant and Kickstarter money and spending it on a good psychotherapist.

Read Next: Why As A Black Man I Prefer White Women In My Games

Feb 28, 2015Sam Roberts
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
Gamasutra's Leigh Alexander Attacks Bioshock Creator Because He Won't Hate #GamergateSJWs Fail To Block Adam Baldwin From Attending Supanova
More From Reaxxion
  • If You Support #GamerGate, Rich Stanton Wants To Kick Your Ass

  • Realistic Medieval Experiences Will Certainly Offend People

  • Wikipedia Editor Tries To Blame #GamerGate For Charleston Shooting

Don't Miss Reaxxion's Best Articles!
Every Monday we send an email that recaps the week. Enter your first name and email below to make sure you don't miss out...

We guarantee 100% privacy
Your information will not be shared

Sam Roberts

Sam Roberts is the ethics officer for Reaxxion. Think we're doing something wrong? Want to chat? You can follow him on twitter, or email him from our ethics policy page.

February 28, 2015 News
Top 5 Posts Of The Week

  • Parasite In City Is A Great H-Game That Is Full Of RapeParasite In City Is A Great H-Game That Is Full Of Rape

  • Booth Babes And Sexy Cosplayers Are In Danger Of Being Completely Banned From EventsBooth Babes And Sexy Cosplayers Are In Danger Of Being Completely Banned F...

  • Portal 2 Is One Of The Most Disappointing Sequels Of Recent TimesPortal 2 Is One Of The Most Disappointing Sequels Of Recent Times

  • Reaxxion Is ClosingReaxxion Is Closing

  • Should Gamers Stop Using The “Rape” Word?Should Gamers Stop Using The “Rape” Word?

Amazing Email Newsletter
Don't miss a post! Every Monday we send an email that recaps the week. Enter your first name and email below to make sure you don't miss out on our best articles...
We guarantee 100% privacy
Your information will not be shared
Recent Posts
  • Reaxxion Is Closing
  • Crusader Kings II Will Steal All Your Free Time
  • Will Half-Life 3 Ever Be Released?
  • 3 Things Games Must Not Apologize For
  • Z Nation Is Actually Kind Of Awesome
RSS Newest Articles From Return Of Kings
  • Return Of Kings Is Going On Hiatus
  • How To Conquer Writer’s Block
  • 2 Signs To Identify A Liberal In Disguise
  • Comfort Will Not Give You Meaning In Life
  • The Devolution Of The West Can Be Seen Through Popular Sports
RSS Newest Articles From Roosh
  • The Best Exegesis Of The Four Gospels
  • The Salvation Of Your Soul Is Not A Game
  • 13 Tips To Improve How You Read Books
  • It’s Not Easy To Escape From The Occult
  • Stop Eating Seed Oils Challenge
RSS Latest Forum Threads
  • How to respond to a pro-abortion point.
  • Prices, Inflation/Deflation, Interest Rates & The Fed
  • Economic effects of the Russo-Ukrainian War
  • "The Great Reset" plan by the World Economic Forum
  • COVID meme thread
  • Weight Loss Help
© Kings Media 2014-2015 • About • Advertise • Submissions • Contact Us • Privacy Policy • Terms Of Service